Checking the Pulse of Lake Erie

Ed.: Moihuddin Munawar; Robert Heath

2008. XXI, 640 pages, 115 figures, 104 tables, 14x22cm, 1010 g
Language: English

(Ecovision World Monograph Series)

ISBN 978-3-510-65236-5, paperback, price: 128.00 €

in stock and ready to ship

Order form

BibTeX file


ecology lake erie fish ecologyhealth walter quality


Synopsis/Preface top ↑

A traditional Chinese physician begins by checking the pulse of his patient. More than merely determining heart rate, he examines various levels of the pulse and its energy balance between the two sides of the patient. From this quick examination he can estimate the overall health of the patient and make some assessments of where potential problems may lie. So too, this monograph of current research on Lake Erie covers a breadth of investigations at various depths. Here we “re-check" the pulse of Lake Erie” in several ways and examine the overall status of the health of the patient: the Lake Erie ecosystem. This patient was certainly due for a check-up and reappraisal.
To that end the volume does include some papers that not merely provide a general compendium of current work. Instead, these papers address specific topics related to current issues and assess potential problems that may unfurl in the foreseeable future.

Included here are works from well established research groups, as well as from some of the new investigators in the region. This volume presents reports on the biotic spectrum in Lake Erie, from viruses to fish and birds. The main stressors on the Lake Erie ecosystem appear to be largely due to human-induced activities: Climate Change, loadings of nutrient and toxic materials, release and introduction of aquatic invasive species. Recent reports indicate that the depth-integrated summer temperature of the lake has increased an average of 0.037 ± 0.01oC per year between 1983 – 2002 (Burns, et al. 2005). In this book, Schertzer et al., and Hamblin and Schertzer show that the thermal structure of Lake Erie can be significantly changed in such a way as to reduce duration and extent of ice cover, earlier onset and longer duration of stratification, and possibly a profound change on winter circulation patterns. Indeed, one of the major changes in climate may be an increase in the variability of storm events and their effects on the lake. Although the total P load to the lake has remained near or below the target loads (11,000 MT) mandated by the Great Lakes Water Quality Agreement (1978 as amended, 1987), recent loading pulses in 1997 and 1998 give cause for concern (Dolan and McGunagle 1995). Here, Dolan and Richards report that loadings in these years exceeded target loads not only because of the frequency and duration of storms, but also due to their unusual winter timing. In addition to loading through storm events, the potential for loading from agricultural runoff following irrigation is addressed in this monograph. Loftus and Richards note that irrigation at this time does not lead to significant impacts on Lake Erie water quality, but the amount of ground water that becomes surface water through this activity may become a concern in the future.

The effects of these stressors appear to be far-reaching; indeed it is unclear whether we know the full set of consequences, or even that all consequences of these stressors have yet appeared in Lake Erie. Regular recurrence of increasingly large regions of hypoxia in the central basin, leading to the journalistic hyperbole of “The Dead Zone,” is the most striking of these ecosystem level effects. The causes and consequences of hypoxia in the central basin are not well understood. In the past, regions of hypoxia occurred because of cultural eutrophication that resulted in excessive growth of poorly grazed phytoplankton, largely cyanobacteria, which in turn died, descended to the bottom waters, and decayed, with consequent consumption of hypolimnetic oxygen by heterotrophic bacterial activities. The current regions of hypoxia are not caused in the same way. Here it is shown that total P-loadings are at or below GLWQA target loads (Dolan and Richards), phytoplankton communities in the central basin do not appear to be dominated by “eutrophic species” (Munawar, M. et al., Meilander et al.), and phytoplankton in the bottom waters remain alive and potentially active (Munawar et al.). Whether hypoxia of the central basin in Lake Erie is “caused” by some errant input, or by some other oxygen consumptive process, such as nitrification of ammonium externally loaded from agricultural activities or internally loaded by dreissenid excretion, or is merely a consequence of global climate change (Schertzer et al.) remains to be seen.

The consequences of large zones of hypoxia are not fully understood, and very little attention has been directed to understanding these consequences, especially at the ecosystem level. It is reasonable to expect releases of phosphate in the bottom waters, but releases of certain species of various metal ions can also occur. Especially Fe has been noted to be a factor limiting phytoplankton productivity in the central basin in the summer, but to vary seasonally (Porta et al., 2005). As Twiss indicates here, very little attention has been given to ionic speciation in Lake Erie and to those conditions that may affect ionic oxidation and reduction. This is an important issue, inasmuch as phytoplankton can respond differently to various oxidation states of the same ion, and that response is as likely to be stimulatory as inhibitory (Twiss et al. 2005). Regions of hypoxia can also perturb nutrient availability. N and S cycles both depend on redox potential of the surrounding waters, and P indirectly is controlled by redox potential, via Fe redox. Regions of hypoxia can result in release of large amounts of P and could also lead to great decreases in N through increases in the rate of dissimilatory denitrophication, as nitrate is transformed to N2O and molecular nitrogen, conceivably altering the availability and relative abundance of these critical nutrients. The status of plankton and benthic communities in Lake Erie appears to be changing, and in many respects to be declining.

Phytoplankton species diversity was high across the lake (Munawar et al. this volume) dominated by nanoplankton (2-20um). In general, phytoplankton communities in Lake Erie are not as strongly P-limited as they once were (Lean, et al. 1983, Guildford et al. 2005, Meilander et al., this volume), as shown by comparison of physiological indicators (alkaline phosphatase, P-debt, phosphate turnover rate, and C:N:P stoichiometry). It is likely that factors other than P-loading alone affect phytoplankton growth and diversity. In this volume the role that planktonic bacterial viruses may play in recycling P is presented (Dean et al.). Also, in this volume appears support for the view that P-availability to phytoplankton is controlled by bacterioplankton abundance and phosphate assimilation rate (Gao and Heath, 2005; Meilander and Heath, this volume).

The western basin appears to be more eutrophic than it was a decade ago (Conroy et al., this volume), and the fraction of inedible cyanobacteria appears to be on the rise in the western basin. In this volume is presented a novel Plankton Index of Biotic Integrity (PIBI), based on numerous metrics of phytoplankton and zooplankton structures. The P-IBI indicates an increase in Lake Erie water quality from the 1970s to 1995 but that it declined from mid-1990s through 2002 (Kane et al.). The gradual decline of water quality and increased presence of cyanobacteria in Maumee Bay from 1978 to the present are noted by Moorhead et al. The benthic communities of the lake present a mixed picture of ecosystem health. The appearance of burrowing mayflies (Hexagenia) in the western basin is an indication of improving benthic community health (Edsall et al. 2005). In contrast, the ubiquity of dreissenid mussels in all basins (Dermott, this volume), the decline of gammarid amphipods, and the near extirpation of the amphipod Diporeia are cause for great concern. The decline in amphipod distribution and abundance are unclear, but often it is felt that they have been unable to compete with the dreissenid mussels for food.

Of course, one of the major concerns in Lake Erie for the past several decades has been the introductions of numerous non-indigenous species. The most notable introduction was that of the dresissenid mussels. During the past decade Dreissena polymorpha (zebra mussel) has been largely displaced by its congener, the quagga mussel (D. bugensis); the causes of this displacement are unclear, and its consequences are virtually unstudied (Patterson et al., 2005; Dermott, this volume). Here we review the entire set of introductions of nonindigenous species (NIS) to Lake Erie (Bailey et al.; Zhu et al.). The introductions of NIS are a rate of about one species per year, largely via ship ballast water. It is unlikely that much headway toward preventing such introductions will be made until the pathways of introduction are blocked, most likely by appropriate legislation. Based on 20 manuscripts the monograph provides a holistic treatment of the Lake Erie ecosystem covering a variety of topics. Various papers have been grouped in to three sections namely: Physical regime; Biological regime and Current issues. These papers as indicated above provide an integrated and top down picture of the status of the health of the patient under check up-Lake Erie.

It is hoped that the papers this voluminous volume will provide a current and integrated assessment of the health of Lake Erie ecosystem, and serve its role in providing in-depth information and data to students, researchers, managers and policy makers interested in the conservation and protection of Lake Erie.

Table of Contents top ↑

Dedication. xi-xii
Editorial. xiii-xvii
M. Munawar and R.T. Heath
Foreword xix-xxi
E. Mills and J. Leach
Physical and chemical regimes
Lake Erie Thermal Structure: Variability, Trends and Potential
Changes. 3-44
W.M Schertzer, P.F. Hamblin, D.C.L. Lam
Lake Erie Hydrodynamics: Regime, Variability and Potential
Changes. 45-77
P.F. Hamblin and W.M. Schertzer
Analysis of Late 90s Phosphorus Loading Pulse to Lake Erie 79-96
D.M. Dolan and R.P. Richards
Modelling Phosphorus and Dissolved Oxygen Conditions Pre- and Post-
Dreissena Arrival in Lake Erie 97-121
D.C.L. Lam, W.M. Schertzer, R.C. McCrimmon, M. Charlton, S. Millard
Changes in water quality of Maumee Bay 1928-2003. 123-158
D. Moorhead, T. Bridgeman and J. Morris
Water Use for Irrigation Agriculture in Ohio’s Lake Erie Basin and its
Potential Impact on Lake Erie Water Quality 159-179
T.T. Loftus and R.P. Richards
Current Knowledge of Trace Metal Biogeochemistry in the
Water Column of Lake Erie 181-205
M.R. Twiss
An updated review of contaminant sources and loads in
Lake Erie 207-243
D. Porta and G. D. Haffner
Biological regime
A review of planktonic viruses in Lake Erie and their
role in phosphorus cycling 247-270
A. L. Dean, J. L. Higgins, J. M. DeBruyn, J. M. Rinta-Kanto,
R. A. Bourbonniere, and S. W. Wilhelm
Distribution and Apportionment of Phosphate Between
Bacterioplankton and Phytoplankton in Lake Erie During
Summer 2003 and 2004 271-295
T. T. Meilander and R. T. Heath
An intensive assessment of planktonic communities in the Canadian
waters of Lake Erie, 1998 297-346
M. Munawar, I.F. Munawar, M. Fitzpatrick, H. Niblock, K. Bowen,
J. Lorimer
A Planktonic Index of Biotic Integrity (P-IBI) for Lake Erie: A new
technique for checking the Pulse of Lake Erie 347-367
D.D. Kane, S.I. Gordon, M. Munawar, M.N. Charlton, and D.A. Culver
Declining Lake Erie ecosystem health-Evidence from a
multi-year, lake-wide, plankton study 369-408
J. D. Conroy, D.D. Kane, and D.A. Culver
Changing benthic fauna of Lake Erie between
1993 and 1998 409-438
R. Dermott and J. Dow
Synergistic changes in the fish community of western
Lake Erie as modified by non-indigenous species and
environmental fluctuations 439-474
X. Zhu, T.B. Johnson, and J. T. Tyson
Application of the Primary Production Required model for managing
commercial fisheries in western Lake Erie 475-496
M. A. J. Fitzpatrick, M. Munawar, and G.D. Haffner
Lake Erie Colonial Waterbirds, 1974-2002: Trends in Populations,
Contaminant Levels, and Stable Isotope Indicators of Diet 497-528
C. E. Hebert, D.V. Weseloh, T. Havelka, C. Pekarik, J.L. Shutt,
M. Shieldcastle, and F. Cuthbert
Current issues
Life in the Dead Zone: exploring microbial communities in the oxygen
depleted waters of Lake Erie. 531-559
T. T. Meilander, M. Munawar, M. A. J. Fitzpatrick and R. T. Heath
Abundance of healthy phytoplankton in the hypoxic waters of Central
Lake Erie during the summer of 2004. 561-578
I.F. Munawar, M. Munawar, M. A.J. Fitzpatrick, J. Lorimer
Nonindigenous species in Lake Erie: A chronicle of
established and projected aquatic invaders. 579-603
S. A. Bailey, D. W. Kelly, D. K. Gray, K. Nandakumar, H. J. MacIsaac