Original paper
Modularity of the wrist in extant hominines
Bucchi, Ana; Püschel, Thomas A.; Lorenzo, Carlos
Anthropologischer Anzeiger Volume 80 No. 1 (2023), p. 1 - 12
published: Jan 18, 2023
published online: Aug 25, 2022
manuscript accepted: Jul 5, 2022
manuscript revision received: Jun 23, 2022
manuscript revision requested: Apr 26, 2022
manuscript received: Jul 28, 2021
DOI: 10.1127/anthranz/2022/1558
ArtNo. ESP140008001000, Price: 29.00 €
Abstract
Wrist shape varies greatly across primates and previous studies indicate that the numerous morphological differences among them are related to a complex mixture of phylogeny and function. However, little is known about whether the variation in these various anatomical differences is linked and to what extent the wrist bones vary independently. Here, we used 3D geometric morphometrics on a sample of extant hominines (Homo sapiens, Pan troglodytes, Gorilla gorilla, and Gorilla beringei), to find the model that best describes the covariation patterns among four of the eight carpals (i.e., capitate, lunate, scaphoid, and trapezium). For this purpose, 15 modular hypotheses were tested using the Covariance Ratio. Results indicate that there is a covariation structure common to all hominines, which corresponds to stronger covariation within each carpal as compared to the covariation between carpals. However, the results also indicate that that there is a degree of codependence in the variation of some carpals, which is unique in humans, chimpanzees, and gorillas, respectively. In humans there is evidence of associated shape changes between the lunate and capitate, and between the scaphoid and trapezium. This covariation between lunate and capitate is also apparent in gorillas, while chimpanzees display the greatest disassociation among carpals, showing low covariation values in all pairwise comparisons. Our analyses indicate that carpals have an important level of variational independence which might suggest a high degree of independent evolvability in the wrists of hominines, and that although weak, the structure of associated changes of these four carpals varies across genera. To our knowledge this is the first report on the patterns of modularity between these four wrist bones in the Homininae and future studies might attempt to investigate whether the anatomical shape associations among carpals are functionally related to locomotion and manipulation.
Keywords
modularity • trait covariation • wrist • hominines