This volume is a collection of 17 papers celebrating the research
career of Prof. Roman Türk on the occasion of his 65th birthday and
pending retirement from the Universität Salzburg. The volume begins
with an insightful biographical chapter which provides an informative
background to Türk the person, not just the academic. Living at the
foot of the Alps, it is hardly surprising that he was drawn to the
mountains and he once informed me that he had climbed most, or was it
all, of the nearby peaks. The comprehensive bibliography of published
works gives the reader a clear understanding of the extensive research
interests of Türk the academic.
The second chapter paints a concise picture of some of the many
noteworthy lichenologists who have come from the region of the former
Austro-Hungarian Empire or who have worked on the region’s lichen
flora. The recipient of this volume, through his diverse interests,
more than adequately contributes to this picture.
The remaining 15 papers contributing to the volume cover a wide range
of topics and geographical regions. Ten of the papers are devoted to
systematics or checklists with comprehensive annotations. Three
discuss the potential impacts of climate change on lichen distribution
patterns and the use of lichens as monitors of these impacts, and one
paper examines lichen diversity on calcareous substrata in the
Austrian Alps. The geographical cover reflected in the various papers
extends from Greenland to Antarctica. As with all such compendia, the
detail and quality of the content of these papers varies. However,
such volumes provide a useful vehicle for the dissemination of much
information that may otherwise not be forthcoming and, hopefully, may
stimulate further interest amongst students and researchers
alike. What is pleasing to this reader is the amount of ecological
information provided in many of the taxonomic or biodiversity papers.
It is regrettable that in the paper by Breuss and Berger on Verrucaria
species, a nomen nudum with a description of the taxon in German only
has been introduced as Verrucaria finitima. Under Article 36.1 of the
ICBN (Vienna Code – McNeill et al. 2006) the name must be accompanied
by a Latin diagnosis and designation of a Type specimen. It is
unfortunate that this has slipped through the referee and Editorial
processes. Also, in this paper, four new lectotypes are indicated
without discussion or any indication of the possibility of an existing
holotype. By contrast, in the paper by Hafellner on Polyblastia, the
reasoning behind lectotypification of Henrica ramulosa is clearly and
correctly given. Elsewhere in the volume, in the paper by Tibell and
Frisch, Calicium pluriseptatum is correctly described.
With greater attention being given to potential impacts of global
climate shifts, the lichen flora of polar and alpine regions is
assuming greater importance and three papers include a discussion of
climate effects in Greenland (Hansen), Saxony (Hauck), and the
European Alps generally (Hertel and Schuhwerk). While the paper by
Hauck concerns alpine lichens at subalpine altitudes, it is likely
that these lower altitude studies may yield more informative results
and certainly in a shorter time frame than studies at higher
altitudes. However, as stated by Hertel and Schuhwerk in their
enumeration of Lecideoid taxa from the European Alps, a first step is
the establishment of reliable checklists. This paper, although rather
lengthy, could be taken as a model for the presentation of much useful
and critical information on the taxonomic relationships, distribution
and ecology of lichens from these extreme environments. However, as
evidenced by Hansen’s paper on inland and coastal lichens of
south-west Greenland, there are inherent problems associated with the
long-term study of change in composition and distribution of species
as field methodologies may change as might, of course, taxonomic
interpretations.
Not surprisingly, the volume is largely Eurocentric. This is not
intended as a criticism and there is much information in the papers
that is of relevance to extra- European localities. What may be alpine
in Europe may well be applicable to comparatively low elevations at
higher latitudes. Many European based lichenologists have, over many
decades, investigated the lichen floras of extra-European
locations. Types and other specimens are usually lodged in European
herbaria. Some countries have a requirement that Types and
representative duplicates of other collections be lodged in a
recognized herbarium in the country from which the material has been
collected, in order to retain authentic material of the taxa in the
country of origin. It is evident from some of the taxonomic papers in
the volume that this requirement is not always followed.
The volume is remarkably free of typographical errors. However, in
the paper on Alpine Parmelioid taxa by Thell, Westberg and Kärnefelt,
which is very useful for collectors trying to enumerate collections of
the species of this large group of macrolichens, some text is missing
from the discussion of Parmelina. The key to taxa provided is, for the
most part, mercifully free of the necessity for a detailed knowledge
of chemistry.
The only serious criticism I have of this volume, because of the
future nomenclatural implications, relates to inclusion of a nomen
nudum in the paper by Breuss and Berger. Collectively, however, the
papers provide a very useful compilation of work, particularly on
alpine lichens. The contributors, editors, and the recipient of the
dedication, can be justifiably pleased with this volume.
Rod Seppelt
The Lichenologist, volume 43(5), pp 499-500 (2010), Cambridge University Press