Rapid Evaluation of Sediment
Budgets,
does not pretend to be a complete guide to
sediment budget construction, but it provides a
comprehensive overview of strategies and tools useful
for understanding sediment production and transport in
watersheds.
The validity of a sediment budget then
depends on how wisely these methods are employed.
Effective construction and interpretation of sediment
budgets requires a sound understanding of erosion and
sedimentation processes, experience in field mapping and
in the measurement and analysis techniques to be used,
and above all, good professional judgment. Each area
represents its own difficulties and opportunities, so
analysts must have a strong enough background in
geomorphology and hydrology to take advantage of the
peculiarities of the area to be evaluated, and they must
be creative and open-minded in their approach.
An insufficient number of sediment budget studies exists
to allow statistical evaluation of the accuracy and
reproducibility of the general approach. However, Reid
and Dunne have found that when several trained
geomorphologists are asked to evaluate a process rate,
results agree relatively closely, and certainly to well within
an order of magnitude. Because many sediment budget
applications require only approximate estimates, this level
of accuracy is thought to be adequate.
Construction of sediment budgets is more difficult in some
areas than others. At sites where sediment input is
dominated by large, infrequent events, rates must be
evaluated using as long a period of record as possible. In
such cases, land use may cause small changes in process
frequencies which can strongly affect long-term sediment
yields, but which may not be observable over the time
frame available for analysis.
The most difficult aspects of a sediment budget to quantify
are those involving transport and storage of sediment in
channels. In areas where these components are
particularly important, sediment budgets can often reveal
the process interactions that control channel response,
the types of changes a channel may undergo, and the likely
location of those changes, even if rates cannot be
quantified.
Several examples of rapidly constructed sediment
budgets are provided by the authors. Anyone
interested in constructing sediment budgets for
management applications should find this book useful
as a guide to specific analysis techniques and as a
source of ideas for applying those techniques to
management problems.
STREAM NOTES, April 2004