Contribution

Stochastic processes override deterministic assembly under homogeneous conditions and habitat isolation

Crettaz Minaglia, Melina Celeste; Gianello, Diamela

Image de la premiere page de:

Fundamental and Applied Limnology Volume 198 Nr. 1 (2026), p. 1 - 14

55 références bibliographiques

publié: May 26, 2026
publication en ligne: Apr 28, 2026
manuscrit accepté: Mar 23, 2026
révision final du manuscrit reçu: Mar 21, 2026
révision du manuscrit demandée: Dec 5, 2025
manuscrit reçu: Sep 26, 2025

DOI: 10.1127/fal/1595

fichier Bib TeX

ArtNo. ESP141019801001, Prix: 29.00 €

Télécharger l'aperçu en format PDF Acheter la version digitale

Abstract

Habitat fragmentation in freshwater ecosystems alters dispersal pathways, creating conditions where stochastic processes can dominate the community assembly. We used a controlled indoor microcosm experiment to investigate how phytoplankton metacommunities assemble when dispersal is reduced under environmentally homogeneous conditions. A single inoculum from a Pampean stream was acclimated and distributed into six microcosms, maintained for 11 weeks under identical abiotic conditions. We tested three hypotheses: (H1) if deterministic processes dominated, communities would converge in taxonomic composition and functional attributes despite isolation; (H2) if stochastic processes dominated, communities would diverge in both taxonomic and functional trajectories under identical conditions; and (H3) the relationship between taxonomic and functional dissimilarity would depend on the degree of functional redundancy, with convergence in functional space when redundancy was high, or tighter taxonomic–functional coupling otherwise. Despite identical starting conditions, communities diverged in both richness and abundance trajectories, with relatively high and sustained β-diversity throughout the experiment. Functional composition showed lower dispersion than taxonomic composition, but taxonomic and functional dissimilarity were significantly correlated, indicating partial coupling between community structure and function rather than full functional convergence. Our results support the view that fragmentation itself does not directly cause divergence. By reducing dispersal, fragmentation allows stochastic processes such as drift and priority effects to operate independently across fragments. These experimental insights highlight the potential for stochastic dynamics to drive community divergence in fragmented freshwater systems, and stress the importance of integrating taxonomic and trait-based functional dimensions when evaluating ecosystem resilience.

Mots-clefs

dispersal limitation • stochastic assembly • neutral theory • functional traits • metacommunity dynamics