Microalgae
Aspects of Diversity and Systematics. Volume dedicated to Ursula Geissler
Ed.: Regine Jahn; Barbara Meyer; Hans R. Preisig
1997. 452 pages
Language: English
(Nova Hedwigia, Band 65 Heft 1-4)
ArtNo. ES050006500, paperback, price: 168.00 €
in stock and ready to ship
This Festschrift volume in Nova Hedwigia honours Ursula Geissler on her
65th birthday as well as celebrates her outstanding contributions to
phycology, both through her published work and her service as editor
for 20 volumes of Nova Hedwigia. The 27 papers reflect Geissler's
interest in diversity and systematics, particularly in diatoms. The
first two-thirds of the volume deals with the phylogeny, systematics,
and floristics of diatoms and includes descriptions for two new genera
(Asteroplanus and Fogedia), 15 new species, and three new varieties of
diatoms, as well as five new combinations. The last one-third of the
volume treats systematics, morphology and floristics of a diverse
group of microalgae in other divisions, including papers on each of
the following: Mallomonas of German eutrophic waters, scaled
chrysophytes in Siberia, a new Cryptomonas species, a new
Peridiniopsis species, ultrastructure of the rare chlorophycean alga
Pachycladella umbrina, the desmid flora of two urban German bogs, the
nondesmid phytoplankton community of a highly acidic bog, algal drift
in a small mountain stream, and rediscovery of a rare
nonphotosynthetic protist, Paramastix conifera. Apart from the
three papers on marine diatom taxa, the two papers on new tropical
species, and the paper on Siberian chrysophytes, the papers deal
exclusively with freshwater microalgae of temperate
climates. Furthermore, most of the papers represent Eurasian
collections, with 11 from Germany (mostly in the vicinity of
Berlin). The papers are all well written and are authored by an
impressive collection of well-known and well-respected phycologists
from around the world. Six papers are in German; all others are in
English.
Although all of the papers are of good quality, there are some that
stand out as especially noteworthy. Erwin Reichardt's (Nova Hedwigia
65: 99-129) revision of the species cluster formerly included in
Gomphonema pumilum is an especially important paper given the relative
commonness and confusion surrounding this group. He describes seven
new species and two new varieties of Gomphonema, illustrating them
with numerous light and some scanning electron micrographs. This will
be a critical paper for phycologists working on freshwater diatom
floristics. A similarly important paper, though not so extensive, is
the comparative study of Achnanthidium by Hiromu Kobayasi (Nova
Hedwigia 65: 147-163). Although it deals with only four closely
related taxa, the combination of light and scanning electron
microscopy and careful drawings demonstrates the differences in a
difficult-to-differentiate group of small variable taxa. One hopes
that this paper will stimulate a better treatment of other members of
this common but still poorly understood genus. I was also impressed by
the paper on the new genus Fogedia by Witkowski et al. (Nova Hedwigia
65: 79-98). Not only is a new genus described based on the marine
littoral species Navicula giffeniana Foged, but an additional transfer
and three new taxa are also described and well illustrated, giving the
paper a completeness and thoroughness not always evident in new
generic designations. Although not relevant to a large number of
diatomists, the paper by Shigeki Mayama (Nova Hedwigia 65: 165-176) on
Eunotia valida and Eunotia pseudovalida was exciting to me, because I
have seen both and never felt completely comfortable calling the
latter E. valida. His paper clearly differentiates these potentially
confusing taxa. Two of the diatom papers were especially thought
provoking. Medlin et al. (Nova Hedwigia 65: 1-11) date the probable
origin of the diatoms using a small-subunit rRNA molecular clock
calibration. The origin of not only the diatoms, but also of the
pigmented heterokonts, is postulated. According to their analyses, the
earliest origin for the diatoms was sometime around the
Permian/Triassic boundary (238 to 266 million years ago). This is
considerably earlier than the earliest appearance in the fossil
record, which was in the mid-Jurassic. The trees generated from the
molecular data are also of interest in their own right and demonstrate
the need for molecular data in many groups, particularly the
naviculoid diatoms, which are not included in the analyses in this
paper. The other paper that I found intriguing was the piece by Eileen
Cox on subspecific diatom taxa (Nova Hedwigia 65: 13-26). She reviews
the historical use of such ranks in diatom taxonomy, defining well the
problems and inconsistencies. She then makes a number of pragmatic
recommendations for the future use of subspecific taxa. Her guidelines
would probably reflect the consensus of the majority of diatomists,
but her clear treatment could help bring some standardisation to the
creation of species, varieties, and forms.
Of the papers on diatom floristics and ecology, two were especially
interesting to me. Dokulil et al. (Nova Hedwigia 65: 273-283) examined
the water quality of an unusual habitat, an urban floodwater
impoundment near Vienna. Their treatment is interesting because the
habitat is neither strictly running water nor a lake, and yet the use
of indicator diatoms from established indices gave an accurate
assessment of the trophy and saproby of this system when compared to
other independent measures. Hahn and Neuhaus (Nova Hedwigia 65:
285-298) surprised me with the unusual diatom flora of an agricultural
soil. Navicula lacunolaciniata, a taxon previously known only from
highly organically polluted rivers was the most common diatom in the
soil, a very unusual find. Of the nondiatom papers, there were two
that will likely have broad appeal. Gutowski (Nova Hedwigia 65:
299-335) presents distributional, morphological, and ecological data
for 29 Mallomonas species from 29 eutrophic localities in Berlin.
Weighted means and ranges for temperature, pH, and conductivity are
presented. The paper is well illustrated with 89 transmission electron
microscopy figures. Scheer and Kusber (Nova Hedwigia 65: 385-409)
report on the desmids present in two bogs in an urban reserve in
Berlin. Apart from the value of the illustrations and descriptions of
the desmids, this paper is noteworthy for its call for the
preservation of Sphagnum stands in urban nature preserves. This
sentiment reflects Geissler's early insistence that algae be added to
the list of endangered species in Germany and that diverse aquatic
habitats be preserved for the sake of the algae living in them.
Microalgae: Aspects of Diversity and Systematics is an excellent
collection of papers on the microalgae. It does not contain
experimental ecology or physiology, nor does it have molecular data
beyond the paper by Medlin et al. (Nova Hedwigia 65: 1-11). Nothing in
the volume struck me as revolutionary or trend setting. For the most
part, the papers are good, solid systematics and floristics, research
that is appreciated by algal systematists and ecologists who do
species specific work in natural systems. I would have liked to have
seen a paper about Ursula Geissler herself, including where she got
her degrees, with whom she has worked, a list of all of her
publications, etc. However, she is certainly honoured by the large
number of researchers who wrote excellent papers for her
Festschrift. The book will be of greatest interest to diatomists, and
if funds are available, I would consider the volume a good purchase
for phycologists concerned with taxonomy and systematics of
diatoms. It contains a number of papers to which repeated reference
will likely be necessary. The book is of less importance to
nondiatomists. Certainly it has something of interest for most workers
studying freshwater, temperate climate microalgae, but the nondiatom
topics at the end of the volume are not taxonomically cohesive, and so
the last one- third of the papers will not be relevant as a set to
many phycologists. Nondiatom researchers likely will want to obtain
copies of selected papers from the volume that are of specific
relevance to their research.
Jeffrey R. Johansen
Phycologia, Vol. 37 (4), 1998, p. 315/316